Digital labour platforms decide who gets to work

Pexels

Many freelancers struggle to land projects on online labour marketplaces, even when they’re clearly available for work. Qinlei Wang looks at how search rankings and ratings shape who gets offered jobs. New European protections will soon come into force. But will workers and regulators be able to see these platforms’ harmful decisions clearly enough to challenge them?

Online marketplaces such as Taskrabbit and Upwork match clients with freelancers. In theory, workers have the freedom to choose when, where and how much they work. Yet many stay on these platforms for months while client invitations slowly dry up. Why?

Taskrabbit’s public guidance explains that whether taskers show up in client searches depends on their availability, along with location, pricing and business factors. Upwork says something similar: its Job Success Score affects search ranking and the chances of landing new projects. Of course, these rules help clients decide who to hire. But they also put the platform’s design between workers and what they could earn.

A decade of research shows how these systems work. Alex Wood and colleagues’ 2019 research found that rating and ranking systems steered work away from lower-rated freelancers. In some cases this threatened their livelihoods, even though they stayed on the platform. Alex Rosenblat and Luke Stark’s 2016 study of Uber drivers showed something similar. The company controlled drivers indirectly by keeping information from them. Both studies point to the same imbalance. Platforms can see how work is handed out, while workers mostly see only the results.

Seeing the problem takes evidence

An empty calendar tells you little about how a platform is treating any one worker. A worker might become less visible because of what clients want, falling demand, changes to their profile or the platform stepping in. Each of these explanations means something different to a regulator, yet the worker may see only the end result. Working out who is responsible means knowing what work was available, how the algorithm chose workers and whether their eligibility changed.

Algorithmic control is widespread on online labour marketplaces, though it varies a lot between jobs and services. A 2026 survey by Eurofound and the European Labour Authority (ELA) covered 3,830 platform workers in 15 EU countries. It found that 43% faced comprehensive control: a mix of surveillance, competitive incentives and limited freedom over their work. Because the study used convenience sampling, we can’t simply apply its percentages to all platform workers. Nor does it tell us how ranking changes affect income.

43% of surveyed platform workers faced a mix of surveillance, competitive incentives and limited freedom over their work

Ratings complicate things further, because they are both a market signal and a management tool. Corentin Curchod and colleagues showed how customer reviews left online sellers at the mercy of power imbalances. A worker’s reputation can help clients judge whether they’re reliable. It is the marketplace, however, that decides how much past reviews affect future visibility. So a dispute over a single review can affect whether someone gets work in future.

Protections now cover how work is handed out

The EU Platform Work Directive covers far more than permanently closing someone’s account. Recital 46 and Article 9 include restrictions on access to assignments and require transparency about automated decision-making systems. Articles 10 and 11 provide for human oversight, explanations and reviews of these decisions. A new International Labour Organization convention adopted in June 2026 also deals with platform work. By early November, however, no country had yet ratified it. EU Member States must write the directive into national law by 2 December 2026. Each must fit it into its own systems of employment and enforcement.

The protection a worker gets also depends on how the platform, the worker and their customers are related. The directive’s Article 11 excludes people who also count as business users under the relevant EU regulation. Business users fall instead under the Platform to Business Regulation. Subject to its scope and exemptions, this requires ranking disclosures and complaint procedures. So a worker’s legal status shapes which route to redress they can use.

You can’t review a decision you can’t trace

An effective remedy starts with a clear enough account of the decision being challenged. But when a worker slowly becomes less visible across many searches, with no single decision to point to, proving anything becomes hard. Useful records would link changes in eligibility or ranking to dates, job categories and the work available at the time.

These records should help separate algorithmic filtering from shifts in demand, workers’ availability and customers’ choices. The right comparison will depend on the platform and the type of work. Reviewers could compare similar periods, check whether a rating was recorded correctly, and ask for explanations of any changes still unaccounted for. This lets reviewers scrutinise decisions without assuming wrongdoing every time bookings drop.

New rules should keep the benefits of digital platforms while giving workers practical ways to challenge unfair decisions

Transparency has limits. The Platform to Business Regulation requires platforms to explain their main ranking parameters. But it also protects them from having to disclose details that would let people game the system. Workers and regulators should therefore be able to see the reasons behind significant decisions, while client information and commercially sensitive details stay private.

The test for national implementation

As countries bring the directive into national law, these protections will clash with the realities of privately run labour markets. A European implementation tracker shows that Member States are taking different approaches and are at different stages of preparation. Oversight will only work if a drop in available work is clear enough for the right body to investigate.

The new regulation should retain the flexible benefits offered by online digital platforms, while giving the workers on them practical ways to challenge unfair decisions

Digital platforms offer a real way into paid work, and their matching systems help customers find the right people. The Eurofound and ELA survey also shows that platform work opens doors for people facing barriers elsewhere in the labour market. A credible system of regulation should keep those benefits while giving workers practical ways to challenge unfair exclusion or inaccurate records. An active account should mean more than permission to wait for work that never comes.

This article presents the views of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the ECPR or the Editors of The Loop.

Author

Photograph of Qinlei Wang
Qinlei Wang
Independent Researcher

Qinlei is a graduate of King's College London.

She works across political science, political economy, digital governance and the sociology of institutions.

Her research examines the relationships between institutional authority, technological systems, social inequality and the production and use of evidence.

Qinlei's interests encompass algorithmic governance, digital labour, education and employment, public administration, political participation, artificial intelligence and digital culture.

Her publications and wider research engage with questions of legal and institutional accountability, evidentiary reliability, socioeconomic inequality and the governance of digital infrastructures.

LinkedIn

ORCiD

Read more articles by this author

Share Article

Republish Article

We believe in the free flow of information. Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Creative Commons License

Close

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Loop

Cutting-edge analysis showcasing the work of the political science discipline at its best.
Read more
THE EUROPEAN CONSORTIUM FOR POLITICAL RESEARCH
Advancing Political Science
Unless otherwise stated, articles on The Loop are published under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0) licence. Images are not covered and remain subject to their individual credits.
© 2026 European Consortium for Political Research. The ECPR is a charitable incorporated organisation (CIO) number 1167403 ECPR, Harbour House, 6-8 Hythe Quay, Colchester, CO2 8JF, United Kingdom.
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram